S

Sachin

Question 4CommentGS1GS1

In light of the declining trend of violence in the North East and J&K region do you think that AFSPA has lived its utility? Comment. (Answer in 150 words) 10 Marks

Open scan (p.11)
AnswerStrengthsGapsKeywords

Introduction

Armed Forces Special Power Act enacted in 1958 gives the armed forces wide ranging powers to maintain public order in areas designated as 'disturbed'.

24 words

Main Body

Declining trend

Ministry of Home Affairs Annual report 2021 - 70% decline in number of insurgency/violence related incidents in North east region
Jammu & Kashmir Police data indicate decline in number of civilian casualties & active militants in J&K region.

AFSPA lived its utility

1Justice Jeevan Reddy Committee recommended repeal of the act & introduction of new law that would provide adequate legal protection to armed forces ensuring human rights protection
2Bezbaruah committee recommended repeal but only in areas where it is not necessary

[Diagram: flowchart with 'Other issues with AFSPA' branching to 'Undermining democracy', 'Unfettered powers', 'Federal issues', 'Lack of accountability']

However, AFSPA is still needed

1Rise in recent number of ethnic conflicts & insurgencies in North East (ex) Kuki-Meitei conflict of Manipur
2Abrogation of Article 370 and continued tensions in Jammu & Kashmir necessitate AFSPA
3Extraordinary situations like violence need extraordinary measures to control it
4Constitution in its preamble & DPSP prioritises sovereignty & integrity of the nation

Therefore, AFSPA is not just a question of security but also of development. Once development is done & local police become capable, AFSPA can be repealed

— Sachin

194 words5 paragraphs2 bullet points

Conclusion

Therefore, AFSPA is not just a question of security but also of development. Once development is done & local police become capable, AFSPA can be repealed

26 words

  • Data-backed argument on declining violence
  • Cited Jeevan Reddy Committee

Open original scan

Page 11

Steal this copy's techniques PremiumAI pulls out the reusable moves — pick the ones you want as flashcards
Compare my answer PremiumSee where this topper beats you

Topper

Sachin

Subject & Paper

GS1GS1

Topic

Post-independence Consolidation and Reorganization

Internal Security - AFSPA

AFSPA and North East/J&K

Writing Stats

244

Total words

5

Paragraphs

2

Bullets

Linked PYQ

1. अधोनिर्दिष्टानां विषयाणां पर्यालोचनं सोदाहरणं विधीयताम् (150 शब्दपरिमितम्) : 10×5=50 1.(a) कुमारसम्भवं कालिदासस्य कलायाः सुन्दरसृष्टिरस्ति । 10 1.(b) भगवद्गीतायां कर्मयोगमधिकृत्य एकां टिप्पणीं लिखत । 10 1.(c) नैषधीयचरितं कलापक्षपातिनां काव्यानां मुकुटमणिरस्ति । 10 1.(d) स्वप्नवासवदत्ते स्वप्नदृश्यस्य नाटकीय महत्त्वं प्रतिपादयत । 10 1.(e) वर्णकरप्रणीत- 'शिवराज्योदय'स्य शैलीसौन्दर्यं प्रपञ्चयत । 10

50M2015विधीयताम्