Introduction
20 words
Main Body
NITI Aayog has arisen as the principal advisory body post 2014 replacing the Planning Commission, promoting cooperative and competitive federalism.
Promoting Competitive Federalism:
Leverage of reports/indices to track relative performance, ex: Liveth Bharat Index.
Incentivise states to perform better in crucial sectors, ex: school ranking in terms of learning outcomes – PGI 2.0
Gamifying social responsibility, ex: Increased public participation.
Promoting Competitive Federalism:
Follows a bottom-up instead of top down approach, ex: Advisory consensus role unlike the Planning Commission.
Participation of states unlike earlier, ex: CME are invited to the Governing Body
Consensus-based decisions ensure better implementation, ex: PMU under Invest India (for better investment)
Expert Advice ensures evidence-based persuasion, ex: Unlike command models of Running Commission
However, it suffers from a few parallels:
Purely advisory nature of recommendations, ex: Armchair theorizing w/o ground impact.
Conflicts between states stymie progress, ex: No consensus on key issues
Regional diversity needs customized solutions, ex: Potential of no-uniformity pair India.
Political quandaries and lack of enough capacity, ex: No more lateral entry.
Thus, NITI Aayog needs to be bolstered further to realise the ideal of federalism by resolving these issues and lead to, 'Sabka Saath, Sabka Utkkas'.
— Amrit Mahapatra · AIR 121
Conclusion
25 words
- Clear explanation of role of NITI Aayog
- Specific examples with current schemes
- Comparative analysis with Planning Commission
- Practical examples of bottom-up approach
- Balanced analysis with weaknesses
- Reference to govt catchphrase
Amrit Mahapatra
Federal Structure - Functions, Responsibilities, Devolution of Powers and Finances
Federalism
Competitive Federalism and NITI Aayog
250
Total words
14
Paragraphs
Analytical
Tone